by Janie Chang
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Fourth Princess is a lovely combination of historical fiction, what Janie Chang is know for, and gothic mystery. The reveals caught me by surprise in two instances (while three others were what I expected). This is, however, a good enough ratio (without having anything too convenient happen) that I can say it was an enjoyable story overall. My favourite points are, of course, the most gothic ones. I loved the mansion and its atmosphere, our ghost, and learning more about Chinese superstition. I know the Chinese tend to be very superstitious and Chang certainly portrays that here; as well as shares tidbits of culture including wards to deter the bad and how much ‘evil’ a Chinese household staff can endure before heading for the hills.
A stand out moment for me is the diary entries of our absent, but still close to the narrative, Rosaline. It’s impressive that the diary entries give enough sense of our missing woman that I felt she was a character all on her own; even though we never actually interact with her. I also adored the many languages, and mixture of Western influence on China during this time period which Rosaline seems to embody (as does the crazy Princess). Although, it reminded me how much I hate that Western culture is always so pushy about its ‘ways’ and so disrespectful of others. I try to take solace as a Canadian (Chang is also Canadian) that we embrace many cultures here; but I know we are also suppressing so much more than we should.
I was glad to get a brief overview of the politics of the day. While on one hand it might have been nice to gain a better understand of the political chaos; I’m also glad not to as it was complex and I felt I got just enough to feel the anxiety of our characters living on the cusp of a great change. If you are interested in the intricacy of the politics as the last Emperor falls you may be disappointed as this story mostly revolves around the mansion mystery and our characters personal experiences.
Overall I feel this is a solid mixture of historical fiction (with many facts throughout as Chang always has) and a flavour for the gothic. It’s not quite at the same gothic level as Silvia Moreno-Garcia but it was just enough gothic atmosphere to keep me going. It helps I was pleasantly surprised at the complexity of the ending reveals. I will confess, I might give this only four stars if not for adoring Chang and having met her whilst in the midst of reading this book. There is always something a bit special about hearing the author talk, in person, about what inspired their book and why they chose the people and topic they did.
All caveats aside, you won’t go wrong with this read if you want some gothic mystery threaded with the clash of Chinese and Western culture of the day. And be sure to savour the diary entries as they truly speak out from the page in a captivating way.
Follow me on Goodreads
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Fourth Princess is a lovely combination of historical fiction, what Janie Chang is know for, and gothic mystery. The reveals caught me by surprise in two instances (while three others were what I expected). This is, however, a good enough ratio (without having anything too convenient happen) that I can say it was an enjoyable story overall. My favourite points are, of course, the most gothic ones. I loved the mansion and its atmosphere, our ghost, and learning more about Chinese superstition. I know the Chinese tend to be very superstitious and Chang certainly portrays that here; as well as shares tidbits of culture including wards to deter the bad and how much ‘evil’ a Chinese household staff can endure before heading for the hills.
A stand out moment for me is the diary entries of our absent, but still close to the narrative, Rosaline. It’s impressive that the diary entries give enough sense of our missing woman that I felt she was a character all on her own; even though we never actually interact with her. I also adored the many languages, and mixture of Western influence on China during this time period which Rosaline seems to embody (as does the crazy Princess). Although, it reminded me how much I hate that Western culture is always so pushy about its ‘ways’ and so disrespectful of others. I try to take solace as a Canadian (Chang is also Canadian) that we embrace many cultures here; but I know we are also suppressing so much more than we should.
I was glad to get a brief overview of the politics of the day. While on one hand it might have been nice to gain a better understand of the political chaos; I’m also glad not to as it was complex and I felt I got just enough to feel the anxiety of our characters living on the cusp of a great change. If you are interested in the intricacy of the politics as the last Emperor falls you may be disappointed as this story mostly revolves around the mansion mystery and our characters personal experiences.
Overall I feel this is a solid mixture of historical fiction (with many facts throughout as Chang always has) and a flavour for the gothic. It’s not quite at the same gothic level as Silvia Moreno-Garcia but it was just enough gothic atmosphere to keep me going. It helps I was pleasantly surprised at the complexity of the ending reveals. I will confess, I might give this only four stars if not for adoring Chang and having met her whilst in the midst of reading this book. There is always something a bit special about hearing the author talk, in person, about what inspired their book and why they chose the people and topic they did.
All caveats aside, you won’t go wrong with this read if you want some gothic mystery threaded with the clash of Chinese and Western culture of the day. And be sure to savour the diary entries as they truly speak out from the page in a captivating way.
Follow me on Goodreads
1 comment:
A gothic novel but set in China? Colour me intrigued!
Post a Comment